What Editing My Novel Taught Me About Cutting

The first full draft of my last novel ran to 140,000 words. The version that went to print was 92,000. Losing a third of the book was painful, and it was the best thing that happened to it.

Cut the scenes that only explain

Many of my early chapters existed to explain things the reader could work out for themselves. Once I trusted readers more, whole chapters became a single line of dialogue.

Merge characters who do the same job

I had three friends of the main character, each with a backstory. Two of them did the same thing in the story. Combining them gave one stronger character and saved twelve thousand words.

Watch for these words

  • Just, really, very and quite, which rarely add anything.
  • Started to and began to: people usually just do the thing.
  • Stage directions like "she turned and walked to the window" when "she went to the window" will do.

Read it out loud

Reading the whole manuscript aloud took two weeks. Every sentence I stumbled over got rewritten. It is the single most useful editing step I know.

Cutting isn’t losing work. It is finding the book that was buried in the draft.

Keep a cuts file

Nothing I removed was deleted. It all went into a separate document. Knowing it was safe made it much easier to be ruthless, and a few of those cut scenes became short stories later.